Floor Guard Vs. Bubble guard as a tile protector

Floor Guard Vs. Bubble guard as a tile protector

 
Description
Bubble guard
Floor Guard
Usage
 One time use becomes costly Economical and Reusable
Structure
Short sheets contains air bubble Long five layered Sheet
Application time
Lengthy for tapping as too many joints. Fast less tape required as joints are less
Protection between tiles and sheet
It has hard surface and can scratch tiles from inner dust particle It has soft surface cannot scratch tiles but sustains impact of inner dust particle
Protection after application
Limited floor protection.
It make permanent mark of bubbles on tiles.
Complete vertical and horizontal protection.
No marks after usage.
Health
Dust appear from too many joints
It is a slippery material.
Healthy and clean atmosphere as less joints.
Skid free and anti slippery material.
Skill
Only skill worker can do application Do application yourself
Maintenance
As joints are more needs to tape frequently One time application for floor protection
Durability
Made from air bubble which cannot comes in original shape once air comes out after compression.Easy tear able and not scratch resistance.Too many joints cannot durable until site completes Made from filled polymer Comes in original shape after compression Highly scratch and tear resistance.
Less joints keeps site clean and tidy.
Tear from holes and scratches
It can get tear vertical once scratched Cannot tear vertical or horizontal as it has a cress cross layer. And can easily tape at scratch and holes.
Salvage Value
Less as aired. Good value after multiple use
Appearance
Sheet form Roll form each roll comes in packing
Handling
 Sheet form many labor required Roll form light weight easy to carry many rolls.
Use in sky scraper
Requirement on each floor Reuse it from one to another